Wednesday, January 3, 2018
What's in a name? (Again)
Some years ago I had to choose a name for my art practice. Now I am returning to this, as I am starting a Facebook artist's page (facebook.com/GordonMonroArtist) and an Instagram page (instagram.com/gordonmonroartist). It is apparently necessary to have a label that is at most three words long, in accordance with the idea of an "elevator statement" (U.S. usage, but "lift statement" sounds odd): you find yourself in a lift with an influential person: you want to tell them what you do, but you only have the time it takes the lift to travel a couple of floors.
My practice is to write computer programs that generate all or most of an artwork. There is an established name for the practice where artists set up systems (computerised or not) that generate artworks, and that is generative art. I would like to call myself a generative artist; unfortunately the term isn't well known, so it needs explanation; no good for elevator statements.
"Process artist" also needs explanation, and an artist's "process" generally refers to the personal process an artist goes through when making or developing work, such as reflecting on events or personal experience, gathering material, and so on. This is quite different from setting up a system that then makes the art.
"Computer artist" brings to mind someone who uses tools like Adobe's Photoshop and Illustrator to make art, which is not what I do.
I thought about "programmer/artist", since I write programs as part of my practice. But I am not a professional programmer, and "programmer/artist" (or "artist/programmer") emphasises the programming side too much. For me programming is a means to artistic ends. Also I don't want to use "software artist", as "software art" has had the meaning of art, made in software certainly, that is about software (and about the way governments and big corporations use it); my art is not about software as such, nor about its political implications, except in a very indirect fashion.
I have a similar problem with "mathematician/artist". It is quite a while since I have been active as a mathematician. I certainly use ideas from mathematics as one of the major inspirations for my work, and I use a certain amount of relatively low-level mathematics while writing my programs, but "mathematician/artist" over-emphasises the mathematical side (even if it might be good branding).
So the best three-words-or-fewer approximation I can think of is still "digital media artist". If I am allowed five words I could say "generative artist (digital media artist)", but it would have to be a long lift journey.
Saturday, July 23, 2016
My PhD exhibition
Where: Monash University Caulfield campus (next to Caulfield station). I am in the MADA Faculty Gallery on the ground floor of Building G (not to be confused with MUMA, which is in Building F).
When: August 10-16. Gallery hours are 10am-5pm Mon-Fri. The gallery will also be open on Saturday 13th August, 10am-12noon.
I expect to be at Caulfield pretty much throughout the duration of the exhibition, including the weekend viewing on the Saturday morning.
Tuesday, March 19, 2013
Exhibition in Bendigo
La Trobe University Visual Arts Centre (VAC): 121 View St Bendigo (across the road from the Bendigo Art Gallery).
Tel: 5441 8724
Web: http://www.latrobe.edu.au/vac
Hours: Tuesday to Friday 10am - 5pm, weekends 12 - 5pm.
Exhibition dates: 27th March to 5th May 2013.
Opening: Wednesday 27th March, 6 - 8pm.
Friday, February 22, 2013
Exhibition in Ararat
For my show there won't be a formal opening, but there will be a closing event on Sunday 14th April.
Arart Regional Art Gallery: Corner Vincent Street and the Western Highway, Ararat, in the Town Hall building.
Tel: (03) 5352 2836
Web: http://arts-events-tourism.ararat.vic.gov.au/ararat-regional-art-gallery
Hours: Mon - Fri: 10am - 4.30pm; Sat, Sun, public holidays: 12 - 4pm.
Exhibition dates: 14th March to 14th April 2013.
Closing event: On Sunday 14 April 2013 at 3pm. I will be presenting an illustrated talk on Generative Art, followed by celebratory drinks at 4pm.
Friday, November 2, 2012
Ten Questions Concerning Generative Computer Art
Tuesday, December 13, 2011
"Bagdad, 1000: The Origin of the Pixel"
From about the eighth century to the thirteenth the Islamic world was the place to be: the arts, the sciences and philosophy flourished in a manner not matched in the Christian West. The West indeed learnt from the Islamic world: "algebra", "alkali" and "sugar" are Arabic words, as are the names of some of the prominent Northern hemisphere stars such as Algol and Betelgeuse. One of the first mathematics books printed with movable type was Euclid's Elements (Venice 1482); the text was in Latin, translated from the Arabic, as a Greek text did not become available in Western Europe until after 1500. The contribution of the Islamic world to Western civilisation has been under-appreciated, and attempts are now being made to better recognise this contribution. Enfoldment and Infinity is a very well-informed addition to this discussion.
Marks's book compares two bodies of art, Islamic art and new media art, especially that based on computer algorithms; she calls both "aniconic": the perceptible image is not the most important part of the art. Islam generally prohibited the use of images of people or animals in religious contexts; in some places (though by no means everywhere) the prohibition was extended to secular works as well. An extraordinary aniconic art arose as a consequence, based on calligraphy, geometric forms and plant motifs, incidentally giving us the word "arabesque". Marks's book makes numerous and striking comparisons between Islamic art and art of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, including cinema and new media art.
How does the history of the pixel come into this? In Chapter seven, Marks discusses two constructs in Islamic art and philosophy that might relate to the pixel. One is an architectural technique based on the repetition of a single cell-like form and used to construct remarkable domes. The other is an atomistic philosophy holding that the created universe consists of indivisible atoms, developed in the ninth century by philosophers known as the Mu'tazila. At least one writer conceived of these atoms as square or cubical. But this tells us nothing about the genealogy of the pixel, and Marks does not make any historical link between these developments in the Islamic world and the pixel as we now have it. Nor does she discuss a much more obvious predecessor of the pixel, the mosaic tile.
So, let's make up another origin of the pixel. A fundamental property of a pixel in a raster display is that it is addressable: I can specify a pixel with a notation like (2, 21), meaning a pixel that is two along in the horizontal direction and 21 down in the vertical direction. Iannis Xenakis considered coordinate geometry to be a gift from music to mathematics: on a musical staff time is measured horizontally and pitch vertically. Furthermore in Western musical notation both pitch and time are discrete; time is measured in multiples of some small unit (the semibreve in older music) and pitch in semitones. I can specify both coordinates with a phrase like "the G (or, the note on the second line of the staff) on the first beat of bar 17". So we have a two-dimensional addressable array of discrete entities. I conclude that the pixel originated in Western musical notation of the thirteenth century. Except that it didn't. (And I don't think there is an Islamic link here. Some Western musical instruments derived from Islamic sources, but the notation is indigenous to the West.)
In fairness, Marks warns us that her genealogies may be fictitious. In the first chapter she says "I exploit ... unsought connections perversely, to behave as if there were a historical continuity where at times there is not". Indeed she tells us that Islamic atomistic philosophy was not transmitted to the West. She goes on to say: "if someone puts down this book believing that the Mu'tazila atomists invented the pixel ... that is fine by me". A strange attitude for a scholar and teacher, but one that is necessary to bear in mind while engaging with the book; and it is an engaging book.
Thursday, February 3, 2011
What’s in a name? (What is computer art?)
On my website I have called myself a “digital media artist”. I don’t like that name very much; I would like to call myself a “generative artist”, but that would require an explanation. What I have not done is call myself a “computer artist”.
This is on my mind because I have been reading a short book called A Philosophy of Computer Art, by Dominic McIver Lopes (Routledge, 2010). I agree with much of what is in this book: there are interesting discussions of various topics, including “What is an artwork?”, and a vigorous defence of computer art against various attacks; the discussion extends to computer games. My biggest problem with the book is with the title: it should be called A Philosophy of Interactive Computer Art.
Lopes makes two central definitions, of “digital art” and of “computer art” (more precisely of the “computer art form”).
Digital art: An item is a work of digital art just in case (1) it’s art (2) made by computer or (3) made for display by computer (4) in a common, digital code. (Lopes p. 3)
(Here “display” has a broad meaning, so it includes sound and other forms of output.)
Computer art form: An item is a computer art work just in case (1) it’s art (2) it’s run on a computer (3) it’s interactive, and (4) it’s interactive because it’s run on a computer. (Lopes p. 27)
If Lopes had called this the “interactive computer art form” I would have little quarrel with it. As it is, I have two main problems with this definition. Firstly, it is too late. For most people, “computer art” brings to mind works made using programs like Adobe’s Illustrator and Photoshop; indeed this is why I don’t call myself a computer artist. Lopes’s book will not change this.
Secondly Lopes’s use rules out works that are computer art under any reasonable definition. Black Shoals by Lisa Autogena and Joshua Portway (http://www.blackshoals.net/), which is not discussed by Lopes, is a work that has virtual creatures breeding and evolving, feeding on real-time stock-market data. The work would be inconceivable without a computer, it changes in real time, and it is unpredictable, but according to Lopes’s discussion of the term “interactive” Black Shoals is not computer art, so by implication is lumped in with Photoshop collages and the like under “digital art”.
The difficulty arises because Lopes wishes to identify computer art as a new art form, as different from (for example) photography and painting as they are from each other. For Lopes, an art form is an appreciative art kind, defined as follows:
Appreciative art kind: A kind [of artwork] is an appreciative art kind just in case we normally appreciate a work in the kind by comparison with arbitrarily any other works in that kind. (Lopes p. 17)
Lopes goes on to argue that digital art is too broad a category to be considered an art form in this sense, which is surely true, and that (interactive) digital art is an art form in his sense; here I think he has drawn his boundaries too narrowly. Black Shoals can surely be appreciated by comparing it with a work like A-Volve by Christa Sommerer and Laurent Mignonneau (http://www.medienkunstnetz.de/works/a-volve/), which also involves virtual creatures breeding and evolving, but where visitors can specify “DNA” for the creatures and interact with them once they are “born”. Yet for Lopes, A-Volve would count as belonging to the computer art form and Black Shoals would not.
If there is an art form that Black Shoals and A-Volve both belong to, what is it? I approach this via two more questions:
- What is the most important characteristic of the computer? My answer: the computer autonomously carries out complex calculations and data manipulations. Interactivity is certainly not the most important characteristic; interactive computing only became widely available at least 20 years after electronic computers were introduced.
- Is there an art form that has complex processes carried out autonomously as a defining characteristic? Yes: it is generative art.
Generative art refers to any art practice where the artist uses a system, such as a set of natural language rules, a computer program, a machine, or other procedural invention, which is then set into motion with some degree of autonomy contributing to or resulting in a completed work of art. (Philip Galanter “What is generative art? Complexity theory as a context for art theory”, available at http://www.philipgalanter.com/downloads/ga2003_paper.pdf)Two generative artworks, then, can be compared via a discussion of the rules or “procedural inventions” involved in the work. Black Shoals and A-Volve use very similar rules: they both make use of evolutionary ideas concerning breeding, mutation and survival of the fittest; altogether clearly they are similar works and are appreciated as such. The fact that one is interactive and the other isn’t is a relatively minor consideration in this case, and surely does not make the works so radically different as to force them to belong to different art forms.
Not all generative art is computer-based: for example Sol Lewitt’s wall drawings made according to systems of rules are generative art under Galanter’s definition. But the ready availability of computers has lifted generative art to a new level and, in my view, has made it visible as a distinct art form. (I also note that Lopes concedes that theoretically a work of computer art in his sense could run on a human brain rather than a silicon machine.)
Most unfortunately, Lopes does not discuss the concept of generative art at all. If one is looking for an art form that makes essential use of the characteristics of the computer, and that has been given both an enormous expansion of possibilities and recognition as a distinct kind of art by the availability of the computer, generative art is a strong candidate.
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Design After Nature Exhibition
- Venue: Guildford Lane Gallery, 20-24 Guildford Lane, Melbourne (near Melbourne Central station).
- Exhibition dates: 3rd - 20th December 2009
- Opening: Thursday 3rd December, 6-8pm.
- Gallery hours: Wed-Fri 12noon - 9pm; Sat, Sun 12noon - 5pm
People involved: Oliver Bown, Joel Collins, Aland Dorin, Alice Eldridge, Mark Guglielmetti, Indae Hwang, Troy Innocent, Taras Kowaliw, Jon McCormack, Gordon Monro, Yun Tae Nam, Ben Porter, Mitchell Whitelaw.
All welcome!
For those on Facebook, there is a Facebook Event for the opening.
View Larger Map
Sunday, June 21, 2009
Galanter's complexist manifesto
Galanter discusses modernism and postmodernism in the context of complexity theory from science. He sees post-modernism as offering a corrective to some of the unfortunate aspects of modernism, but now post-modernism has fallen has fallen victim to its own problems. Galanter's Complexism is intended to reconcile the two via the theory and practice of complex systems, and he presents the following table:
| Modernism | Postmodernism | Complexism |
| Progress | Circulation | Emergence and Co-evolution |
| Fixed | Random | Chaotic |
| The Author | The Text | The Generative Process |
| Authority | Contention | Feedback |
| Truth | No Truth | Incomplete truth known to be not fully provable |
| Pro Formalism | Anti Formalism | Form as public process not privilege |
| Hierarchy | Collapse | Connectionist networks |
There is a lot to be unpacked here. Galanter expands on the table in the 20 pages of the article, which is online at http://philipgalanter.com/downloads/complexism_chapter.pdf. He has also started a blog in which he intends to further develop these ideas, at http://www.philipgalanter.com/complexism/index.html.
I am certainly pleased to see work like this proceeding beyond the now sterile debate of modernism versus postmodernism, and especially work that deals seriously with some of the extraordinary advances in scientific thinking of the last half-century or more.
Friday, November 30, 2007
Galeyev’s “Periodical System of Art”
A post by W. Shawn Gray on the iota list made me aware of the article “Periodical System of Art” by Bulat Galeyev (http://prometheus.kai.ru/sis_e.htm). Galaeyev classifies artforms on a two-dimensional diagram, with the vertical axis running from visual arts to audio arts and the horizontal axis running from “figurative and verbal arts” to “expressive (nonfigurative) arts”.
Galeyev organises the arts into three concentric rings. In the centre is the cultural practice of societies such as Aboriginal society, which fuses what we would call dance, singing, painting and so forth into one practice (labelled “folkloric” by Galeyev). The next ring has eight boxes containing the usually recognised artforms such as music, dance, painting and so forth, with some nuances. Thus singing is a pure audio art, balanced between the figurative and non-figurative poles; of its two neighbours, music is somewhat nearer the non-figurative pole and “art of word” somewhat nearer the figurative pole.
The outermost ring (16 boxes) contains newer artforms enabled by technology, such as TV (balanced between audio and visual art, extremely figurative or representational). I can place what I want to do in the box exactly opposite, namely art balanced between audio and visual art, but not at all figurative. Galeyev labels this box “light-music”. I think that this is distinct from visual music, which at least in part is conceived as a visual equivalent of abstract music, and probably belongs in Galeyev’s box “dynamic light art”. I found some of the labels hard to understand, as the explanation is condensed and there is a problem of translation.
I found Galeyev’s diagram thought-provoking. According to it, the nearest traditional art-form to “light-music” is dance, which is a connection I certainly hadn’t considered. I’m not sure what to make of this.
Galeyev doesn’t consider generative art in this article. It occurred to me that there could be a third axis running from free improvisation at one end, to a middle position where most aspects of the work are fixed, but by an artist working fairly intuitively (e.g. an orchestral score), to pure algorithmic art at the far end. This is an axis of immediacy of intuition. Since almost all artforms fall pretty well in the middle of this axis, this third axis would only give a slight three-dimensional thickening of Galeyev’s planar diagram!